Length at birth an indicator of risk for Wilms' tumor? - Researchers at the University of
Bergen examined the relationship between length at birth and incidence of the kidney cancer
Wilms' tumor in 1,489,297 children born in Norway between 1967 and 1992. Their results,
published in the October, 1996 issue of the British Journal of Cancer, listed 119 cases aged 0-14
years, among whom a high length at birth was associated with a greater risk for the tumor, with
a risk ratio of 1.8 for a length over 53 cm (20.9 in) compared with one of less than 49 cm (19.3
in). A low Apgar score, a measure of overall infant health in terms of respiratory effort, heart
rate, muscle tone, reflex activity, and color, also suggested a higher risk (risk ratio of 2.2 for a
score less than 8 versus one greater than 9). However the relationships only held for those
children less than 2 years of age, in whom the disease may have a different cause than in older
children. (Heuch, Br J Cancer 74:1148, 1996)
Editor's Comment: - As with many other examples of increased risk for various kinds of cancer
associated with particular factors, the findings need to be kept in perspective. The annual
incidence of Wilms' tumor in the US is around 6 per million children. The incidence in the
Norwegian study is similar, just over 3 per million. A doubling of the risk still does not
constitute an epidemic, and is no reason for parents to panic if their newborn infants are above
the normal length. In fact, with epidemiological studies of rare diseases it is frequently
impossible to be sure the results do not reflect chance alone even if large numbers are involved,
as in the present study.